What do we think happens to the privileged but unqualified students who gain admission to elite schools only because their parents manipulate the system?
Not surprisingly, the students don’t change. They are still unqualified, so need to channel their energy — and that of their parents — into getting grades they haven’t earned. Their presence in classrooms is typically a net drain on the academic community.
Here’s a professor at an elite U.S. institution, writing anonymously:
“Students who can’t get into elite schools through the front door based on academic merit don’t change once they’re in class. They can’t do the work, and are generally uninterested in gaining the skills they need in order to do well. Exhibit A from the recent admissions corruption scandal is “social media celebrity” Olivia Jade Gianulli, whose parents bought her a place at the University of Southern California, and who announced last August to her huge YouTube following that “I don’t know how much of school I’m going to attend. But I do want the experience of, like, game days, partying … I don’t really care about school.”
Every unqualified student admitted to an elite university ends up devouring hugely disproportionate amounts of faculty time and resources that rightfully belong to all the students in class. By monopolizing faculty time to help compensate for their lack of necessary academic skills, unqualified students can also derail faculty research that could benefit everyone, outside the university as well as within it. To save themselves and their careers, many of my colleagues have decided that it is no longer worth it to uphold high expectations in the classroom. “Lower your standards,” they advise new colleagues. “The fight isn’t worth it, and the administration won’t back you up if you try.”
In comparing stories, we have also found that such students strive to “work the system”, using university procedures to get the grades they desire, rather than those they have earned, and if necessary to punish faculty who refuse to accede to those demands. It is perhaps unsurprising that students whose parents circumvent the rules to get them into elite universities are often the ones who become adept at manipulating the university system in a corrupt way.”
Poster boys for unqualified students cheating their way through school and benefitting from academic credentials they didn’t earn are Trump and his son-in-law, Jared Kushner.
Hard to tell this anonymous professor that his assessment is wrong, and that he should take a stand in the interests of academic integrity.
Pam Klainer's Day 